By Eddie Pannone
We all stood up and applauded Red Sox GM Ben Cherington after he constructed a championship roster in 2013. He was able to trade unwanted and unneeded salaries, was able to find good players that gelled together and was able to hire the right manager to lead the team. While he obviously didn’t play in any games, he was as big a reason as any why the Boston Red Sox won the World Series.
In 2015, he is the biggest reason why his club sits in last place.
Cherington ignored obvious flaws with the club while trying too hard to fix other ones. 2014 saw a team that couldn’t hit or pitch and his offseason saw him address the need for hitting. The need for a big bat was easy to see, but the need for a front line pitcher was needed just as much.
With an outfield producing no offense at all, Cherington’s first move really came in August when he signed Rusney Castillo to a 7-year, $72.5 million contract. With a young Mookie Betts ready to shine, a veteran in Victorino whom the organization claims to have full faith in when healthy, and Brock Holt who showed he could handle any position and produce, it would seem that the outfield was taken care of. The team also had Daniel Nava, Jackie Bradley and Allen Craig who could play outfield on their bench.
So what are their two big offseason moves? Signing Hanley Ramirez and Pablo Sandoval to long term deals. To be clear, I like both of them as players, but the way the roster was constructed it just didn’t make sense. Of Castillo, Ramirez and Sandoval there was only room for two on this team. If Cherington thought that highly of Castillo, then either Ramirez or Sandoval made sense to fill third base. If the team really thought Ramirez could play left field (which so far doesn’t look like a good prediction), then the acquisition of Sandoval makes sense but the signing of Castillo doesn’t.
Castillo and his big contract were wasted away in Pawtucket for the beginning of the season while Ramirez struggled to handle left field. Meanwhile the Sox rotation, which could have used a front line starter like Jon Lester, James Shields (both free agents) or Cole Hamels, struggled with starters failing to reach expectations that weren’t that high to begin with. Wade Miley has been up and down while the man they traded away for him in Rubby De La Rosa has pitched more innings, struck out more batters, and issued less walks. Yoenis Cespedes, who the team got for Jon Lester, was traded away for Rick Porcello who has also been up and down all year. The only free agent pitcher signed was Justin Masterson, who Cherington hoped the club could turn around. It was a good idea, but not at the $9.5 million price tag.
Had some of that money invested in one of those offensive players been used to acquire a pitcher, some pressure would have gone off the staff on every start knowing they didn’t have to do too much. Players would feel much more comfortable in their roles and this team could be in a much better spot.
Cherington needed to address the organization’s needs, and while it looks like he made moves to address them they were not nearly adequate enough. The moves he made have not worked out well and the construction of the roster seemed to play a very little role in his moves. Unfortunately for this club, there doesn’t appear to be a miracle move that can turn them around. They have to rely on the players they have turning things around and at this point over performing. That is a scary position to be in, but one Cherington and the Red Sox put themselves in.